Skip to content

Why Lean Isn't Always Healthy

Especially for Women

Lizzie Bell4 min readHealth
Two photographs side by side: a woman taking a mirror selfie in gym kit, and a shirtless man holding a barbell

If you’ve ever looked at a shredded six-pack and thought “that’s the goal,” you’re not alone.

This is VERY common, with many of us having being sold the idea of low body fat being the ultimate marker of health and i

But is it?

A while back, I decided to go through a dieting phase to remind myself of how it felt and the easy traps to fall into whilst dieting so I could better relate to my clients.

I lost over 6KG and was sitting around 12-15% body fat.

Coach Connor also did a similar thing and was around 8-10%(see photo below!).

Aesthetically, we look like stereotypical health and fitness professionals and maybe some people’s gym goals.

And some of you might even believe we look like this the whole time!

But the truth is actually very different.

To get my body fat this low, I was constantly hungry. My energy tanked. My hair was thinning. And my menstrual cycle had disappeared — a clear sign my body was not happy!

Connor was also very hungry and running very low on energy at that point — but as a man, being at the lower end of his healthy range (8-18%) has less impact on his hormones and health than it does for a woman at the lower end of hers.

He could sit lower than me without the same hormonal fallout.

Why the difference?

Women naturally carry more essential fat than men. Our bodies need that fat for hormone production, for our menstrual cycle to function, for fertility.

Men’s essential fat isn’t tied to reproductive hormones in the same way, which is why they can drop lower before their body starts pulling emergency levers. For women, low body fat hits harder and faster — it directly disrupts estrogen production, which is why a disappearing period is often one of the firstwarning signs, alongside hair thinning, low energy, and constant hunger (all of which I experienced first-hand). Over time, that drop in estrogen can also affect bone density, increasing the risk of issues like osteoporosis down the line.

But men aren’t immune either — very low body fat can tank testosterone and cause fatigue too. But the threshold for that damage tends to be lower for men, and they don’t have a menstrual cycle acting as an early warning sign the way women do.

For women, a healthy body fat range is generally more like 15-25%. Below that, your body starts sacrificing the things it needs.

For men, that floor is much lower — typically 8-18% is considered a healthy range — because they simply don’t carry the same biological requirement for essential fat.

So you could actually argue that a six-pack and very low body fat on a woman is even less healthy than the same look on a man — even though we’re conditioned to think it looks equally “fit” on both.

The big point here is that lean and healthy are not the same thing!

Here are some key things I want you to take from this;

  1. Stop using visible abs as your health benchmark. A six-pack tells you almost nothing about whether your hormones, cycle, or energy are functioning properly. And for women it is also affected by where you store the body fat you have. Some women have flat stomachs and abs whilst storing a higher amount of fat around their hips for example.
  2. Track how you feel, not just how you look. Energy levels, sleep quality, hunger cues, and — for women — a regular menstrual cycle are far better health indicators than a number on a scale or how defined your abs are.
  3. If your cycle has disappeared, it’s a sign your body is under too much stress. And being too lean is one of the contributing factors to this. This is a signal, not something to push through.
  4. Understand your realistic, healthy range. For women, that’s roughly 15-25% body fat. And if you’re serious about health then this is where it is best to stay!
  5. Getting lean short term for something like a photo shoot can be fun to do (like Connor did for example). BUT it is not a good idea to try and stay like that long term. Day to day myself and Connor stay in a higher and healthier range than in those photos. And as a result we feel energetic, can perform in the gym and have way better health markers!

Have a great week

Lizzie

The One Percent Club

Train with the people who write this

One-to-one coaching at our private Marylebone studio. Tell us what has stopped working and we will give you an honest answer about whether we can help.

07590 622020

Monday to Friday, 6am–9pm

We reply the same working day. Your details are used only to get back to you. See our privacy policy.

Or call 07590 622020. We are open Monday to Friday, 6am to 9pm.

Call the studioEnquire